CompareComparison
Judge.me vs Stamped
Judge.me is a focused, flat-priced, search-friendly reviews app. Stamped is a solid mid-market platform that brings reviews and loyalty together. Both do the classic job well, and there is a newer option that also turns reviews into search traffic.
Verdict
Between these two: choose Judge.me for focused reviews at a flat price, a free plan and solid crawlable markup, and choose Stamped if you want reviews and loyalty in one tool and one bill. Both are dependable, established platforms. If you want your reviews to display well and also grow your traffic, BeyondReviews is the newer option: every review answered in your voice, the phrases your customers repeat put where Google and AI answers read them, and nothing published until you approve it. It is free to start.
- BeyondReviews: Stores that want reviews to bring in traffic, not only to reassure the shopper already there.
- Judge.me: Stores that want affordable, indexable reviews with a free plan.
- Stamped: Mid-market brands wanting reviews and loyalty in one tool.
Which is right for you?
Do you want loyalty in the same tool?
If yes, Stamped brings reviews and loyalty together in one platform. If reviews are the job, Judge.me is lighter and has a free plan. If you want reviews to do more than reassure, BeyondReviews stays focused on reviews and the traffic they bring.
Which is cheaper to start?
Judge.me. It is free to start and $15 a month flat for the paid plan. Stamped removed its free plan and trial in 2025, so you start on a paid plan from $23 a month on the App Store. BeyondReviews is also free to start, up to 100 orders a month with no card, and Chorus with phrases on the page begins at $29.
Which is better for SEO and AI search?
Between these two, Judge.me: its server-readable markup and JSON-LD make review content easy for crawlers and AI to read, while Stamped supports rich snippets through its widget. BeyondReviews keeps that standard, with reviews in the page HTML and schema on every plan, then adds what gives Google and AI answers something to quote: replies and approved phrases written from your customers’ own words.
Each tool in detail
Judge.me
A focused, flat-priced, search-friendly choice, with a large App Store review base.
Judge.me · Strengths
- Free plan with unlimited reviews and requests
- Flat $15 a month, no volume caps
- Server-readable HTML plus JSON-LD
- 5.0 stars across 47,402 App Store reviews
Judge.me · Trade-offs
- Reviews only, no native loyalty
- Default widgets are functional rather than premium
Stamped
A solid mid-market reviews-and-loyalty platform, lighter than Yotpo, with both programmes in one tool.
Stamped · Strengths
- Reviews and loyalty in one platform
- Strong in-email review collection
- 4.7 stars across 3,753 App Store reviews
Stamped · Trade-offs
- No free plan and no free trial since 2025
- Starts at $23 a month, with photo and video on every plan
- Reviews load in a JavaScript widget, which crawlers that do not run scripts do not read
BeyondReviews
The new way of running reviews. It collects and displays them like Judge.me and Stamped, then puts them to work so they bring the next buyer to the page.
BeyondReviews · Strengths
- The classic job on every plan, free included: photo and video reviews, Google stars with Review and Product schema, every widget, unlimited review requests
- Chorus counts the phrases your customers repeat on each product; a phrase counts once three customers have used it
- The reply desk drafts an answer to every review in your store’s voice and works one of those phrases in where it fits. Nothing publishes until you approve it, and one- and two-star replies never carry phrases
- Approved phrases are printed into the product page’s own HTML, where Google and AI answer engines read them
- Issues, Copy gaps and Pulse show what customers complain about, what your page never says, and whether the reason they bought held up
- Free up to 100 orders a month with no card; Chorus and phrases on the page from $29. Every price is published
BeyondReviews · Trade-offs
- Focused on reviews and the traffic they bring: no loyalty programme or subscriptions
- Newer than Judge.me, so without its years of App Store reviews
By the numbers
- $0 vs $23
- Judge.me free plan against Stamped entry priceVendor pricing, June 2026
- 47,402 vs 3,753
- Shopify App Store review countsShopify App Store, checked September 2026
- 0
- Major AI crawlers that run JavaScript. GPTBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot read the page as it arrives, so the words that get quoted are the ones in the HTMLVercel and MERJ, December 2024
- +12%
- More reviews once a business starts replying to them, and ratings rise tooProserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science 36(5), 2017
Frequently asked questions
Does Stamped still have a free plan?
No. Stamped removed both its free plan and its free trial in a 2025 restructure. Plans start at $23 a month on the App Store.
Is Judge.me good enough without loyalty?
For reviews, yes. Judge.me is a solid, popular review app. If you want a loyalty programme too, you would pair it with a dedicated loyalty app or choose a platform like Stamped.
Which is better for search visibility?
BeyondReviews. Judge.me is better than Stamped for crawlable markup, and BeyondReviews keeps that standard and adds replies and phrases written from your customers’ words, printed into the page where Google and AI answer engines read them.
Can I move to BeyondReviews from either?
Yes. Your reviews import as part of setup and count toward your rating from day one, keeping your Google stars through the move is treated as our problem, not yours, and you can export everything at any time.